Look inside

Novels

Unconventional Hearts (Plum Valley Cowboys Book 3)

4.1(17)
Paperback€18.50
Not availableFree shipping
Buy Now

About the book

One summer. Three men. The proposal that ropes them together.CooperI came to Texas with a single goal: to find my bio-dad before the end of summer. Instead, I found Will, a spitfire of a man with sharp blue eyes and a swoon-worthy drawl. When he proposes adding benefits to our newfound friendship, I'm all in.The problem? I'm smitten. With not one, but two men. Because Will has a friend that makes me smile like no other. My time in Plum Valley is coming to an end, but if I'm not careful, I'll be leaving my heart behind when I go.WillSpending summer break back home with my best friend was not supposed to be complicated. But then Tru and I kissed, and for the first time, I don't know where we stand. Now Cooper, the new ranch hand, is mixed up in matters, and I'm even less sure of what it all means.The three of us fit together effortlessly, but I worry it's only a matter of time before someone gets hurt. I don't know how to get out of this tangled mess, and truth be told, I'm not sure I want to.TruTo me, it's simple. Will and I are exploring what it means to go from friends to more. But as an asexual man, there are certain activities I'm uninterested in. Will likes Cooper, and Cooper is all about Will. And me? I have no problem sharing.But as summer ticks down, I learn a few lessons. One, I feel more at home in Plum Valley than anywhere else. Two, I've been harboring major feelings for Will. And three, Cooper's infectious optimism isn't something I'm ready to part with.Time's almost up. Yet I'm nowhere near ready to say goodbye.Unconventional Hearts is a lighthearted poly romance between a Southern charmer with a hero complex, a blunt-as-can-be sweetheart who doesn't need saving, and a lovable golden retriever of a man who has a song for every occasion. There is no cheating and one very HEA. It's book 3 in the Plum Valley Cowboys series but can be read as a standalone.

Editions (1)

ISBN9781967130085
PublisherEmmy Sanders
Publication Date11/20/25
Pages334

Reviews & Ratings

17 ratings

2 reviews

4.1

Tap to filter

  • 4.5

    This was beautiful! Really sweet ace rep, a small town that feels more like home with each book, good chemistry, well written characters with own motivations and deeper backgrounds AND a flowing writing style (that also seems to get better with each book)! I only wish there would have been more time for them to explore their relationship altogether, but on the other hand that could have meant lengths, so it kinda worked this way as well!All in all a really, really sweet story about three men finding their soulmates.

    Sep 30, 2025

  • 5.0

    Haha, my polyamory and ace love was satisfied! Eyy loved it! Tru's Asexual identity and how he describes it-yep, loved it! I loved that he wasn't jealous when Will slept with Cooper. Tru encouraged it and explained that sex has a different meaning for him; he sees it as a simple need that Will has, and he trusts him completely-approved, loved it! Honestly, without Tru, nothing would have happened because Cooper was too afraid to even ask if they would take him in, and Will was seriously like his dads, too scared to open his mouth. Tru, you made this work. I genuinely loved everything about how their individual relationships progressed, as well as their relationship as a throuple. Loooved it.

    Oct 27, 2025

Reading is better with the READO app.

Discover books, track progress, read together.

Library

Keep track