☆☆ 2 stars • cheating with no good explanation • didn't feel the chemistry... we were told that they had history and we know of activities and things they liked to do but we have to trust that they once loved each other • no grovelling • male protagonist is definitely in lust with her body (which he and his d*** let us know every time he saw her) didn't really get the feeling that he was in love with anything else (like her mind) • 3/4 were pretty boring... the most interesting part came in the last 1/4 of the book • waited for forever for things to happen that were hinted at from the start of the book which ended up to be pretty disappointing (*spoiler* Jenny sees her father in prison, Nikan does the show on his ancestry) I feel like that would have been to much research and backstory so we only got a glimpse • Thomas and Harrys story was the most emotionally engaging and exciting part of the book • pretty disappointing after reading 'Elliott Redeemed' • overall the characters didn't feel all that fleshed out, the other band members got portrayed in a different light than I felt I got to know them in die other books, Nikan wasn't convincing me in winning Jenny back